Advisory Banner

ADVISORY

ADVISORY NEWSLETTERS

Blockchain for CRE: Future Promise vs. Current Reality

Blockchain technology is largely shrouded in hype and obscured by hyperbole. Like many groundbreaking innovations, the promise of blockchain has far outpaced the practical development. It is important to understand how blockchain is being applied to the real estate market today, and how those applications are expected to mature in the future. To help cut through the haze, we offer below an overview of the current state and future promise of one of the most impactful blockchain real estate applications, real estate tokenization.

Tokenization is a catch-all term that can be applied to nearly any aspect of the blockchain industry. In this article, we will use the term “tokenization” to refer to tokenized securities. Tokenization can be simply thought of as a form of securitization, selling fractional interests using blockchain-based capital markets for liquidity instead of traditional markets such as the NYSE. This was pioneered by a trio of venture capital firms: Blockchain Capital, Science Blockchain and SPiCE VC. Each company raised capital by tokenizing their funds: either entire LP equity positions or future cash flows from investments. This process revealed benefits in liquidity, investor management and transactional efficiency that can be applied to real estate.

LIQUIDITY
Future Promise:
By tokenizing an asset, the issuer gains access to an expanded pool of liquidity. Instead of being limited to the regional investors and the 9:30 AM – 4 PM trading hours of a traditional exchange, tokens trade freely across borders and at all hours of the day. This global pool of investors and round-the-clock order book will unlock additional liquidity premiums and pricing efficiency. Each of the VC fund pioneers were able to raise over $10 million for their funds, indicating positive investor demand in a nascent market.

Current Reality: There have only been one or two tokenized real estate offerings, which have not yet generated the same demand as the VC offerings. The return profile of real estate is radically different than the returns offered by blockchain companies or the VC funds that invest in them. Entreaties about the risk-adjusted returns and long-term stability of real estate vs. crypto have fallen on deaf ears. This is partly because blockchain capital markets mainly provide access to global liquidity from retail investors, who generally do not understand the benefits of diversification or risk-adjusted returns as well as institutional investors. Retail liquidity also pales in comparison to that offered by institutional investors, who so far have been barred from the market by a lack of custody, insurance, and sophisticated products.

There are many companies working on these solutions, and institutional interest from the sidelines has been extensive. Tokenization platforms like Slice RE have further prepared for the entrance of institutional investors, by tokenizing popular institutional investments like LP equity positions in commercial real estate.

INVESTOR MANAGEMENT
Future Promise:
Blockchains are basically just ledgers, keeping track of who holds what token at any time. By layering on security token protocols (aka smart contracts), an issuer can automate compliance with regulations, operating agreements, PPMs and lender requirements. Lenders do not have to rely on a borrower’s good faith to inform them of changes in the capital stack. Programmable securities can automate the process of dividend payments and create software interfaces for the execution of equity rights.

Current Reality: Lenders are concerned about the commitment of small investors in highly fractionalized cap tables, and don’t yet understand the compliance benefits of smart contracts. Therefore, obtaining leverage on tokenized capital structures can be difficult. Smart contracts are new software and have suffered failures in the past as pioneers have iterated best practices. Securitize, Harbor and Polymath are leaders in the creation of secure, compliant security token protocols. They have taken up the mantle of educating institutional investors and lenders on the benefits of tokenized investment structures.

TRANSACTIONAL EFFICIENCY
Future Promise:
The title to a property can be vested in a single token, reducing transactions from complex multi-party processes to a simple transfer between buyer and seller. The token’s history is publicly auditable, simplifying the title research and insurance process. Such a token can be placed into a smart contract wallet that acts as an autonomous escrow, holding the seller’s property token and the buyer and lender’s cryptocurrency proceeds in escrow until all parties assent to the exchange.

Current Reality: The real estate market is just starting to experiment with cryptocurrency transactions, with no more than a couple dozen deals completed, mostly in the residential space. Startups tackling transactional efficiency include HouseHodl, Velox.Re and Propy. This vertical will probably continue to see sluggish adoption as it requires the acceptance of institutions and the general public. Institutions will likely continue to experiment with blockchain for back-office use cases before getting comfortable enough to roll out public-facing blockchain software. Until institutional adoption and introduction, the general public is unlikely to adopt the technology on a large scale.

CONCLUSION
Informed, rational investors should continue to be wary of startups that promise massive disruption on short timeframes. This can be difficult in a highly volatile market, where newly-announced ventures raise tens of millions in a heartbeat from eager investors foaming (or fomo-ing) at the mouth to get in on the next big winner. Nonetheless, the achievements and progress of the pioneering startups noted in this article are laying the groundwork for new, efficient, automated, and global capital markets within the next decade. Each successful implementation eases the path for further innovation and adoption, accelerating the rate of change. Every real estate professional should keep abreast of this developing technology, or risk being left behind when it explodes into the mainstream.

Henry Elder, Director of Origination & Investment, Slice
Henry Elder (@Henry_Elder ) is the Director of Origination & Investment for Slice, a real estate tokenization platform. He has participated in over $1 billion of debt and equity investments across real estate and tech. He also speaks internationally on topics such as asset tokenization, cryptoasset valuation, and tokenomic design.

This Week’s Sponsor

CBRE, a Fortune 500 company headquartered in Los Angeles, is the world’s largest commercial real estate services and investment firm based on 2017 revenue. It employs 80,000 people and serves real estate investors and occupiers through approximately 450 offices worldwide. CBRE offers a broad range of integrated services, including facilities, transaction and project management; property management; investment management; appraisal and valuation; property leasing; strategic consulting; property sales; mortgage services and development services. Please visit our website at www.cbre.com.

Realcomm News

CORE TECH 2018
The World's #1 Conference on Corporate Real Estate, Facilities,
Technology & Innovation is Returning to Silicon Valley!

Join the most innovative Corporate Real Estate and Facilities executives from companies such as Google, Exxon Mobil, JLL, Intel, McKesson, LinkedIn, American Express, Salesforce, Wells Fargo, CBRE and many others, as they gather to discover, discuss and debate how technology, automation and innovation will continue to impact the next generation of how we use and operate corporate facilities.

Watch this brief video and learn more!

UPCOMING REALCOMM WEBINARS

A Path to Net Zero – Driving ENERGY EFFICIENCY in Smart Buildings - 7/18/2019

One of the first trends to emerge in the modern smart building movement was energy conservation and efficiency. Approximately eight years ago, the industry realized that connecting energy related equipment to a network and applying advanced analytics and complex integration strategies could result in a significant reduction in energy and natural resource consumption and a resultant decrease in energy related expenses. In recent years, operational efficiency and occupant experience have been added to the smart building discussion, sometimes overshadowing energy efficiency. This webinar will focus on the very important goal of including energy efficiency in the comprehensive smart building strategy.

headshot for Ruairi Barnwell
Ruairi Barnwell DLR Group
Ruairi Barnwell Energy Services Leader, Principal Ruairi is a respected high-performance building design expert. His aim is to elevate the built environment and restore order to the climate for future
headshot for Ruairi Barnwell
Ruairi Barnwell
Energy Services Leader, Principal
DLR Group

Ruairi is a respected high-performance building design expert. His aim is to elevate the built environment and restore order to the climate for future generations. He specializes in commissioning services for new and existing buildings, building energy assessments, high performance building design, energy modeling/advanced building simulation, and measurement and verification consulting.

headshot for Sarah Zaleski
Sarah Zaleski U.S. Department of Energy
Sarah Zaleski Senior Advisor Sarah Zaleski currently serves as a Senior Advisor for the U.S. Department Building Technology Office where she leads commercial zero energy efforts,
headshot for Sarah Zaleski
Sarah Zaleski
Senior Advisor
U.S. Department of Energy

Sarah Zaleski currently serves as a Senior Advisor for the U.S. Department Building Technology Office where she leads commercial zero energy efforts, district-scale solutions, and a portfolio of data infrastructure projects. In previous roles at DOE, Sarah led local government clean energy innovation programs. Sarah has over 15 years of experience in sustainability and energy work. Before DOE, Sarah worked for Baltimore City where she helped establish their Office of Sustainability.

headshot for Ryan Knudson
Ryan Knudson Macerich
Ryan Knudson AVP, Operations and Energy Management Ryan Knudson, is the AVP for Operations and Energy Management at Macerich. He is responsible for the development, execution and operations for all Cap
headshot for Ryan Knudson
Ryan Knudson
AVP, Operations and Energy Management
Macerich
LinkedIn

Ryan Knudson, is the AVP for Operations and Energy Management at Macerich. He is responsible for the development, execution and operations for all Capital Expense Energy and Smart Building projects as well as national program vendor management. He oversees the daily operations of Macerich’s portfolio with a focus on same center NOI growth.

headshot for Akshai Rao
Akshai Rao Yardi
Akshai Rao VP Akshai Rao, a vice president at Yardi, is responsible for the development of procurement and energy management solutions to ensure high-performing bui
headshot for Akshai Rao
Akshai Rao
VP
Yardi

Akshai Rao, a vice president at Yardi, is responsible for the development of procurement and energy management solutions to ensure high-performing buildings. Prior to Yardi, Akshai spent five years at Bain & Company where he focused on technology and telecom.

headshot for Jean-Simon Venne
Jean-Simon Venne BrainBox AI
Jean-Simon Venne Chief Technology Officer Jean-Simon Venne is a tech expert who thrives on developing and implementing new technology to solve long-standing commercial issues. He has over 25 y
headshot for Jean-Simon Venne
Jean-Simon Venne
Chief Technology Officer
BrainBox AI

Jean-Simon Venne is a tech expert who thrives on developing and implementing new technology to solve long-standing commercial issues. He has over 25 years of experience in the fields of telecommunications, biotechnology and energy-efficiency specializing in the fast and efficient migration of technological innovations to commercial applications. With an industrial engineering background, Jean-Simon is uniquely trained to optimize the value creation opportunity that exists where new technology intersects with business and energy markets.

headshot for Gary Fescine
Gary Fescine GFC
Gary Fescine President of GFC Gary Fescine FMA, RPA is the president of GFC his own consulting firm. He has recently retired from BlackRock where he was global director of faciliti
headshot for Gary Fescine
Gary Fescine
President of GFC
GFC

Gary Fescine FMA, RPA is the president of GFC his own consulting firm. He has recently retired from BlackRock where he was global director of facilities, building operations, overseeing 77 sites in 23 countries. He has held a number of related positions including director of facilities at The New York Times and director of operations at the New York Post. Mr. Fescine was the recipient of several energy savings awards including the Energy New York Award in 2017.