Beyond Appraised Value: The Promise of AI-Enhanced Building and Location Scores
Comparing one building to another for the purposes of purchasing, selling, investing, or leasing has long been a subjective exercise best reserved for analysts, brokers, and agents. Valuation methods are primarily based on historical financial data, seemingly arbitrary market pricing, or simply whatever a new buyer is willing to pay.
In a recent article titled, "Five Commercial Real Estate Valuation Methods," Rafael Rosenkranz identified current valuation methods as the Cost Approach, Sales Comparison Approach, Income Capitalization Approach, Value Per Gross Rent Multiplier, and the Value Per Door Method. However, what if there was a more comprehensive way to assign "value" to any building or location? What if a building owner actually earned an aggregated "score" based on hundreds of industry-applied metrics—including the financials? Potential purchasers, buyers, investors and tenants could then filter on prioritized categories and weighted metrics that go well beyond appraised value.
To explore this concept, a group of attendees and vendors at this year’s Realcomm | IBcon conference in Nashville participated in their Investment Management Networking Workshop. Chuck Niswonger, President of NiceNets Consulting, provided an overview of cloud-based data integration from a "Cumulous Perspective"—a term he coined earlier in the conference. (See his blog for a detailed definition.) He gave a brief history of building rating systems, what is accepted in the industry today, and what some vendors are now offering within their own consolidated data set. Chuck then assigned workshop participants the task of generating weighted metrics that would give a more complete assessment of valuation comparisons.
Evolving Rating Systems for Commercial Buildings
When considering building rating systems, we have to include the Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED) standards. This is a "certification program devised in 1994 by the U.S. Green Building Council (USGBC) to encourage sustainable practices in design and development." [Encyclopedia Britannica]. LEED ratings are based on the number of points assigned for green compliance. Prior to 1994, building construction codes were used to measure compliance. A building either passed or failed the minimum accepted standards based on routine inspections results.
Today, other independent rating systems are being adopted such as the WiredScore, a "connectivity rating" based on telecom availability, signal penetration, in-building wireless, and WiFi saturation. Another evolving metric is the WELL Building Standard, "the premier standard for buildings, interior spaces and communities seeking to implement, validate and measure features that support and advance human health and wellness." This includes ratings on Air, Water, Nourishment, Light, Fitness, Comfort and Mind.
New ratings are appearing in enterprise systems such as Moody's Analytics Commercial Location Score. Component weights in six different categories "compute a numerical score which can be used to complement existing site risk and investment assessment analyses."
Realcomm’s Annual Networking Workshop
Given the recent introduction of independent scoring systems, we wanted to provide workshop participants with the opportunity to generate a full spectrum of weighted metrics that might be used to compare one building or location to another. We asked them to consider any source of CRE-related criteria with no restrictions on data analytic challenges that would likely accompany the actual design. Nothing was off limits! They were free to include any available metric no matter how difficult it might be to collect or how uniquely applicable it might be to a single location.
Their task was to generate as many ideas as possible, then group them into logical categories. Over 80 participants, comprised of attendees and vendors, took on this challenge! They worked together to explore how private and public data from multiple sources could be integrated using common data keys and interrogated within a single enterprise system to provide a more comprehensive scoring mechanism. Some groups focused on traditional metrics while others included unusual details around the political landscape, the building’s design or "cool factor" and workplace comfort. Altogether, the workshop participants generated 16 categories with over 150 metrics.
Workshop Output: Categories & Weighted Metrics
This graphic illustrates how categories could be prioritized and filtered using a standard user interface. By compiling the desired metrics, a customized rating system could compare one building or location to another. While this exercise produced interesting results, the actual data collection process brings about numerous and undeniable challenges.
Vendor Reactions and Future Possibilities
We concluded our workshop with a panel discussion made up of representatives from Yardi, MRI Software, Juniper Square, VTS, Realpage, and Reonomy. Julie Miner of CohnReznick, (center, see picture), moderated their reaction to the workshop’s findings and explored the concept of a standardized scoring system that could enhance automated valuations using multiple criteria—beyond appraisal value. The most critical challenges focused on data issues including availability, subjectivity, privacy, anonymity, and quality. Several companies have already recognized the value of this information, but acknowledge that these challenges are extremely complex. If we are to provide meaningful comparisons between commercial structures within any given market, owners must be willing to release private data for broader use. Providing anonymity within an aggregated data set is a stumbling block for the larger institutions who own data from nearly every major market and industry vertical.
The Commercial Real Estate industry is still a long way off in accepting a valuation methodology that will include metrics beyond financials. Advancements in data consolidation techniques and leveraging AI to identify consistent patterns offers great promise in supplementing valuation calculations. Early adopters may initially be limited to data within their own portfolios. As data sets from multiple sources become widely available, artificial intelligence and machine learning advancements will complement accepted assessment methodologies. More enterprise systems will include scoring solutions within future releases as more of these challenges are resolved.
This Week’s Sponsor
Angus Systems is a leading provider of customer driven mobile and cloud-based work order and operations management solutions for commercial real estate. Our software supports over 2 billion square feet across North America in buildings from 20,000 to portfolios of more than 100 million square feet. Visit www.angus-systems.com to learn how we help our clients shine.
UPCOMING REALCOMM WEBINARS
CORPORATE REAL ESTATE & Technology – The Importance of Developing a STRATEGY - 10/24/2019
The Corporate Real Estate industry has quickly gone from constantly resizing the corporate real estate portfolio based on the everchanging business needs of the corporation, to having to understand and deal with a myriad of issues relating to technology, automation and innovation. Not only do CRE professionals need to understand things such as IWMS, intelligent buildings, the smart workplace, AI, VR/AR and other emerging technologies, they also need to understand the fundamental shift on how we use space. Technology which is enabling mobility has shifted the landscape. This webinar will feature some of the most innovative professionals discussing the importance of developing a comprehensive Corporate Real Estate portfolio strategy around the concept of Digital Transformation.
Founder of Realcomm Conference Group, an education organization that produces Realcomm, IBcon and CoRE Tech, the world's leading conferences on technology, automated business solutions, intelligent buildings and energy efficiency for the commercial and corporate real estate industry. As CEO, Jim interacts with some of the largest companies globally pertaining to some of the most advanced and progressive next generation real estate projects under development.
Chuck Niswonger has over 30 years of successful leadership experience in technology-related roles that range from operating his own consulting company (www.nicenets.com) to directing the IT strategy of a real estate investment management firm to manufacturing and technology-enabled education. Chuck has also been the chair of the Realcomm Investment Management (IM) Advisory Council for the last ten years, managing content selection for the conference educational sessions, IM forums, workshops and webinars.
Emmanuel Daniel is responsible for building and delivering the Digital Transformation strategy for campuses across Microsoft and leads a global multidisciplinary team of architects and experience designers. He builds experiences that merge technology with the built environment, leading to the formation of spaces that respond to the needs of its users. He is also accountable for identifying, building and implementing the next generation of products that will make smarter and sustainable buildings.
Paul Maximuk is the Product Owner as well as a technical SME at Ford Land, leading all BMS and controls integrations globally. He has over 30 years of experience in the industry managing multiple types of energy systems and specializing in strategic smart building implementation and management. Paul’s expertise in the built environment spans real estate assets from large industrial facilities to Class A office buildings.
Ronna Davis has been in the networking and telecommunication industry for 23 years. She has been with CommScope for over 13 years and has held positions in sales, channel and product line management. She is currently on CommScope’s Strategy and Technology Team for Buildings and Campuses. Previous to CommScope she worked in the design and construction of telecommunications networks for eight years and in wholesale distribution for two years. She studied marketing and is a LEED Green Associate.
Ron Victor is a Silicon Valley based technology entrepreneur with 20 years of experience and expertise launching new ventures at start-ups and fortune 1000 technology companies. To-date he has enabled raising more than $30Million in start-up capital for multiple start-ups in silicon-valley. Ron has founded and led three companies to-date with successful exits. His latest venture is IoTium Inc. – a Silicon Valley start-up that provides a secure, cloud-managed, easy-to-deploy software defined network infrastructure for all IoT verticals.
Marc is a pioneer in leading the Intelligent/Smart Buildings and M2M movements pushing the industry forward and has contributed to transforming and changing the Intelligent Buildings and M2M (now IoT) industries. As Chief Marketing and Communications Officer for Lynxspring Marc leads corporate and product marketing, strategy, brand management, public relations and communications that support the company’s strategic and growth initiatives.
Brent Boekestein is the CEO of Vintra, Inc., a leading video analytics company from Silicon Valley that uses artificial intelligence to transform any video surveillance into actionable and tailored intelligence. Forward-thinking enterprises and public safety organizations like Sacramento City, NYC DOI, Sacramento County, and more use Vintra’s solutions to organize, analyze, and derive critical insights from overwhelming amounts of stored and live video.